Sunday, February 23, 2014

1 Why I Can't Stand Junot Díaz: Decolonial Love is About Hate, Not Love

Why I Can't Stand Junot Díaz: Decolonial Love is About Hate, Not Love
By: Brandon Archambault

I haven't read any of Junot Díaz's fiction. I plan to get there eventually, but when I critique Díaz, it's for his politics.

Decolonial theory is associated with names like Walter D. Mignolo; if you want a solid critique from someone much more qualified than me of Mignolo specifically and his decolonial bugbears, then the first thirteen pages of this monograph do exactly that.

Díaz, though, is specifically more well-known for talking about “decolonial LOVE,” and that's why I single him out for being intolerable. First, let's step through where Díaz and I are in full agreement on race and love:

First, racism exists in a violently unbalanced asymmetry, which is why the U.S. social justice  (SJ) movement consistently refers to racism as “white supremacy” (often citing bell hooks' support of this change of phrasing): the violence is overwhelming a one-way street. Whatever episodes of violence by people of color (POC) exist, they are dwarfed by the centuries of white violence, white police, white military, white slave-trading, white lynchings, white anti-immigration acts. Even when POC violence is explicitly committed as anti-white retribution, this is not only dwarfed by white anti-POC violence, but is clearly and obviously symptomatic of a universe in which racism is posited by white bodies who claim for themselves the top tier of value, meaningfulness, and right-to-life. (An analogy often used in the SJ movement is the distinction between Israeli and Palestinian violence: an Israeli state that can bomb, kill, demolish, and colonize with international impunity has a monopoly on violence that Palestinian violence can only, at best, weakly retaliate against.)

White supremacy is the thesis, and all other races are the antithesis it generates.

Secondly, in a December 2012 talk, Díaz said, “we are never going to get anywhere as long as our economies of attraction continue to resemble, more or less, the economy of attraction of white supremacy.”

This is where we break, because while I would say the exact same thing, Díaz and I are angrily opposed in what we mean.

Díaz's politics are what Nietzsche condemned in his Genealogy of Morals as “priestly morality,” or “ressentiment;” mine are what Nietzsche called “transvaluation” and Hegel, “sublation.” (Sublation is negation, but negating something at a fundamental level, not merely asserting its opposite: the sublation of white is not black, but colorless.)

Nietzsche wrote a fable to explain what he saw as the historical development of morality in Europe. Originally, the story goes, were the strong, noble, warrior class—who considered themselves Good—who rules over the slaves—by comparison, weak, inferior, therefore Bad—and were supported by the priestly class. But in Nietzche's story, the priests come to resent the warriors' comparative advantage, and teach the slaves to resent all the qualities of the warrior too—their strength, their power, their dominion—as Evil; ergo, since the slaves are the opposite, they must be Good. So began the slave rebellion, led by the priests, getting us today's moral system where political conservatives constantly paint themselves as the poor, abused victims in order to gain moral authority (instead of merely touting the fact that they are rich and powerful and in control—we would resent them for that, instead of meekly obeying).

Applying this story of morality to race—“White being, absolutely, a moral choice,” not some simple question of skin color, as James Baldwin reminds us—whiteness is what calls itself Good; the racial others, the racially “abjected,” the racially “subaltern,” the racial “neo/postcolonial”—to use some of Díaz and the SJ's movements own jargon—are Bad.

But with the priestly revolt, which is the SJ movement broadly and Díaz specifically, we invert the terms: I know that I am Good because you are all these things (racist, privileged, a settler, ignorant) and I am not them; by the process of elimination, since I know you are Evil, I must be Good.

In fact, I am ONLY Good because I am not YOU. And this is what separates Good and Bad from Good and Evil: Bad is the antithesis generated by the thesis Good, but Good and Evil reverses the sequence,  re-evaluates—redeem, in a literal sense, “deem again, value newly”—the antithesis OVER the thesis, calling Bad Good and Good Evil.

Because this is Diaz's project, his only possible move is to invert the terms (and this is what Mignolo does more explicitly): where we were Eurocentric, we now must IGNORE questions deemed “European,” since they “do not matter” for the subaltern of the third world (Gayatri Spivak, who coined the term subaltern, makes exactly this claim in one of her critiques of Jacques Derrida). Where we were once white supremacists, we must value and celebrate the history of the indigenous, the black African, the Maori—well-known things like the slogan “black is beautiful” or poetry and novels written in various creoles or patois. (Remember again that this is an argument relevant almost exclusively to the U.S., not even the English-speaking worlds—neither Díaz nor the SJ movement seem to have the first clue about Maori or Australians who would never identify with the U.S.-centric “AAPI” grouping, since they are referred to, in English, as “blacks” in Australia and New Zealand)

As Kalpana Seshadri-Crooks unforgivingly put it, “Race, if it is working at all, is about the sense of one's exclusiveness, exceptionality and uniqueness. Put very simply, it is an identity that, if it is working at all, can only be about pride, being better, being the best.” Díaz and the rest of the decolonial critics' politics is to do exactly that: assert that they are better, be proud, be the best. Specifically: denigrate all the settler-colonial culture of America called “good” as evil, and assert that what it said was “bad” is actually good! Even those who do not go so far as to engage in things like black supremacy—and Díaz certainly does not—we wind up only with the more common, Democrat-party fantasy where we are ALL able to be the best, we are EQUALLY unique and special and valuable, where the thesis makes its amends to the antithesis, and the two are somehow brought to a future harmony of racial balance and equality.

In a word: I hate you because you are Evil, and that makes me Good. My love for the other Good is a consequence of my hate for you.

(Note: Intra-POC violence—like black-on-Asian violence after Rodney King—fits the pattern Seshadri-Crooks predicts, as documented by Anne Anlin Cheng: black supremacy is a movement of ressentiment which, in the specific case of the King beating, turned into an assault on Korean locals in a display of race supremacy, attempting only to re-order the relative privileges of race.)

This hate of Evil also demands a certain performance of the subjects who are Good: the black body who is insufficiently “authentic” is policed for their false consciousness, as is the lower-class white body who is, somehow, accused of “appropriating” a culture they are much closer to than the sneering academics who found them wanting on their “intersectionality” spreadsheet. The values are inverted, but the freedom of bodies to desire and perform however they choose remains as restricted. Boxes and boundaries are shuffled, but not destroyed.

Sublation (Hegel) or transvaluation (Nietzsche)—whichever you want to call it—does no such thing. Nietzsche's road out of Good and Evil was never to return to the values of the “warriors.” (That interpretation, in fact, is exactly what the Nazis believed and why they popularized his works). We had to revalue ALL things: consider irrelevant what we once desired, prize what was considered, not bad or disgusting or ugly, but totally worthless, unnoticed, unconsidered. This is the mistake Díaz makes: he still makes his decisions about love based on the white economy; he only wants to call pennies dollars and dollars pennies, hate what the white economy loves and love what it hates (thus his love is a function of hate). “Transvaluation,” on the contrary, burns the money up, introduces a new currency, or a barter economy, or a communist utopia, but it treats dollars and pennies both as simply nothing—it is as indifferent to them as you or I are to the monetary value of a snailshell or a hat full of snow. (That is what makes this sublation—from white to colorless—instead of ressentiment negation—from white to black or back again.)

Therefore, what separates Hegel's and Nietzche's critique of love within the white economy form Díaz's is that, paradoxically, Díaz's love is conservative: the thesis (whiteness) and the antithesis (POC) are preserved. Ressentiment attempts to reverse the thesis and antithesis, to negate the thesis with the antithesis, to invert hate and love, which keeps both, but rebrands their values (Good becomes Evil, Bad becomes Good). What Nietzsche called transvaluation and what Hegel called sublation is not about a “synthesis” in which thesis or antithesis are reconciled in unious harmony; sublation eliminates the thesis and the antithesis along with it: to lose white supremacy is to lose all sense of a shared black identity, of being Asian-American, of indigenous history; all of these were retroactively posited by white supremacy to explain its own existence (“We came to the land of noble savages with human chattel and are now fighting against the unwanted racial others trying to share in our prosperity”—all ideological hallucinations with real, material consequences: the genocide of Natives, the enslavement of black Africans, the Chinese Exclusion Act and the present hysteria about Latin@, esp. Mexican, immigrants).This opens the space for a NEW thesis; and that is something decolonial love can only hate: it loses its own identity, its own conviction that it is Good.

More than that: Good is in a struggle with Evil to remake society in its own image; that is when victory is achieved. But transvaluation demands giving up on the illusion of a future, of a future that is “better”: we must live rightly NOW, damn the rotten corpses we'll be and whatever future society rises. It is not about building a new society. It is not about replacing the present culture. It is about YOUR life, NOW.

As Žižek puts it later in that same essay linked above, when it comes to class oppression, “the goal of the revolutionary activity is [not that everyone becomes like workers but], on the contrary, to change the entire social situation so that workers themselves will no longer be 'workers.'” Racially, this is what revolutionary achievement aims for as well: Not that we all become more white (the neoliberal goal) or that we all convert to the side of the oppressed (what the frequently-cited Paolo Freire openly advocates in his “Pedagogy of the Oppressed,” another favorite of the SJ clique), but that THE VERY DIFFERENCE IS DESTROYED. We are made free because these coordinates cease to control us—ANY of us.

"None of us are free until all of us are free," as the now-unpopular slogan goes, since that involves grace for the devil, who must also be released from hell, even though he is the king of it. And we don't want that. We want retribution.

And this, finally, is why the politicians of ressentiment cry “foul” and accuse the Hegelian/Nietzschean radical of being a political conservative: they cannot tell the difference between the two positions, the neoliberal “post-racial” fantasy (which is a simple regression to the point where white supremacy is hidden and invisible again) and the actual elimination of white supremacy and all it generates as a result: racial profiling, the concept of white trash, xenophobic immigration acts—the end of white supremacy means the end of a universe in which these ideas can even make sense.

In the first case of post-racism-as-regression, as Díaz himself knows, white supremacy masquerades as non-existent, as the unmarked position, as common-sense knowledge, not some biased “ideology.” Furthermore, we are all implicated in this, we are all affected by white supremacy. But for Díaz, that means that POC have been duped, are being deceived in to betraying those they should be in solidarity with for the benefit of those who think they are white, sometimes in exchange for minuscule privileges. But however much they have learned to depend on those scraps of privilege to stay alive, they must learn to give them up.

Nonsense. For sublation/transvaluation, the fact that we are all implicated means we are all enabled to fight and destroy white supremacy, no exceptions. None of this imbecility about how “clearly revolution must come the working class women of color as they are best positioned to see white supremacy 'as it really is.'” The ressentiment politician has learned that white supremacy's invisibility is a lie, but is convinced that the impossible is, well, impossible: not only is there no future in which a non-raced subject can exist, they sure as shit can't exist NOW...

And that is where Díaz ultimately reveals himself to be on the side of ressentiment. While we both want to go full Bane in the Gotham Stock Exchange when it comes to “the economy of attraction of white supremacy”—catastrophically destroy it—Díaz wants the colonized to engage in some kind of “return” to a proud past, to achieve a love AGAINST the neocolonial subjectivity they've been raised into.

So it's no surprise that many people like Díaz prefer to cite the passages of White Skin, Black Masks that Fanon immediately disavows at the end of that chapter (like the passages praising black beauty). As you'll see Žižek himself cite Fanon, “I am a man, and what I have to recapture is the whole past of the world. I am not responsible solely for the slave revolt in Santo Domingo. Every time a man has contributed to the victory of the dignity of the spirit, every time a man has said no to an attempt to subjugate his fellows, I have felt solidarity with his act. In no way does my basic vocation have to be drawn from the past of peoples of color. In no way do I have to dedicate myself to reviving a black civilization unjustly ignored. I will not make myself the man of any past.” This runs loudly counter to the “historically-aware, systemic collective action” of most SJ thinkers. The usual objection is that all of this is just an individualistic fantasy (always the consequence of my or someone's else's “unchecked privilege”), insufficiently “structural” and unable to come to terms with “collective action.” What does Fanon's privilege in being able to make the above claim, they would say, do for the 14 year old black boy on the Boston T who's felt worthless his entire life, and then, as Cherrie Moraga knew, gets shot in the head by a cop (see the preface to “This Bridge Called My Back”)?

The very question shows a gross misunderstanding of the problem. It is not Fanon's privilege to ask this question; it is the sign of his liberation. Living in a violently racist, decolonizing world—which is still OUR world!—he asserted his humanity, his freedom from the past that ressentiment politicians and white supremacists alike hoped to bind him too (if for different purposes), his ability to rejoice in all successes and grieve with all defeats. The boy who gave Moraga an existential crisis was robbed of his ability to live that life by a bullet. But until we too are dead, we must employ a practical, pragmatic ability to live in this miserable reality we call home. Decolonial love denies that love in the time of misery is possible; Hegel asserts that the only time is now.

Such a response is also why I detest privilege: as bell hooks naively, even cluelessly, put it in her “post-modern blackness,” “it's easy to give up identity, when you got one.” That is not a thing anyone who has ever tried to give up privilege can respond to except with abrasive, mocking laughter. hooks was specifically trying to defend identity politics as valuable; but what hooks cannot theorize is that privilege is not simply concrete, material goods like access to food, employment, housing, safety, etc.

Privilege is a bribe, and when you have privilege, you have been BOUGHT. To fight against it will go for you about as well as anyone who's ever seen a cop movie knows—the corrupt system will either ignore you (because it can), discipline you (beat you, humiliate you, alienate you, rescind your privileges), or when you cease to be an acceptable level of threat, destroy you.

White racial identity is one such privilege. James Baldwin—who, impossibly, is a favorite of decolonial love fans—knew this, as he wrote in his beautiful “On Being White... And Other Lies.” It is worth quoting at length:

“No one was white before he/she came to America. It took generations, and a vast amount of coercion, before this became a white country.... America became white—the people who, as they claim, 'settled' the country became white—because of the necessity of denying the Black presence, and justifying the Black subjugation. No community can be based on such a principle—or, in other words, no community can be established on so genocidal a lie. White men—from Norway, for example, where they are Norwegians—became 'white' by slaughtering the cattle, poisoning the wells, torching the houses, massacring Native Americans, raping black women... This moral erosion has made it quite impossible for those who think of themselves as white in this country to have any moral authority—privately, or publicly... But this cowardice, this necessity of justifying a totally false identity and of justifying what must be called a genocidal history, has placed everyone now living into the hands of the most ignorant and powerful people the world has ever seen: And how did they get that way? By deciding that they were white. By opting for safety instead of life. By persuading themselves that a Black child's life meant nothing compared with a white child's life. By abandoning their children to the things white men could buy. By informing their children that Black women, Black men, and Black children had no integrity that those who call themselves white were bound to respect. And in this debasement and definition of Black people, the debased and defined themselves. And have brought humanity to the edge of oblivion: because they think they are white, they cannot allow themselves to be tormented by the suspicion that all men are brothers. Because they think they are white, they are looking for or bombing into existence, stable populations, cheerful natives and cheap labor. Because they think they are white, they believe, as even no child believes, in the dream of safety.”

Love will risk its life for the object of love; but the person who thinks they are white will do anything to believe they are safe. This is the opposite of love; this is fear. The person who thinks they are white, in a word, is incapable of love.

But for the SJ thinker and the decolonial critic, this is good! This is privilege! This is what it means to “survive in America”!

BULLSHIT. “[Those who believe they are white] have divested themselves of the power to define and control themselves”—they have given up their freedom! They believe in the delusion that they must do this to survive! They have lost control! They cannot love! And this is GOOD?

BULLSHIT! “White being, absolutely, a moral choice,” it is a choice for evil, a choice against the belief that all men are brothers.

The SJ movement cannot be tormented by the thought that all men are brothers, either; it tastes to them of a conservative lie, a smile standing in front of a knife, a road of broken promises. It is understandable; but it is not acceptable. It is hatred, which is no more love than fear.

As Baldwin observed elsewhere, “So long as you think you are white, there is no hope for you.”

Here, however, we find the final, and perhaps most compelling objection decolonial love can ask: Yes, but so what? That is white people's problem. Are we expected to have sympathy for our oppressed oppressor? Or are we supposed to go even further and claim the same for the antitheses—“so long as you think you are black, that you are a woman, that you are AAPI, that you are American...” you cannot love?

That would be a very stupid thing to assert. The history of European racism makes this obvious: no matter how many times people identified with the antithesis give up their identities, whiteness will find them new ones. Foucault observed in his History of Sexuality that at the end of 19th century sexual perversions were being classified more quickly than they could actually be diagnosed: the well-known homosexual and heterosexual but also “auto-monosexualists, mixoscopophiles, gynecomasts, presbyophiles, sexoesthetic inverts, and dyspareunist women” among others. It is a shame that he did not observe this same process in race, where it had gone on for much longer with names just as bizarre: Celestials, mongoloids, sub-human Slavs, Caucasian, white, Celt, half-caste, mestizo, barbarian, half-orang, Ethiop, Abbyssinian, Aryan, Dravidian, noble savage, redskin, morisco, crypto-Jew.

For the antithesis to redefine itself means nothing for the thesis. That is the concrete reality of the “radical asymmetry” mentioned at the beginning: destroying the antithesis is as good as cutting off the head of a hydra. For those antithesis-identities, the answer is the same as those with a thesis-identity: Burn it all to hell. The freedom of both “oppressor” and “oppressed” depend upon the destruction of white supremacy; neither is capable of love until they cease to love within the white economy.

So Díaz and the SJ movement repeat the mistake when talking about what they mis-call love, and we wind up with all sorts of imbecilic separatism: only black women can stand for black women; there is no shared gender oppression; black lesbians announcing that transwomen are men; the conviction that in “safe spaces” that the privileged parties should learn to shut up and be silent because this fight is not their fight (they're winning, after all—who wants to actually question the goodness of what patriarchy and white supremacy and heterosexism promise its elite, have taught them to desire?) and on and on.

To learn to desire outside the white economy is NEVER, EVER to want what it tells you NOT to want—to simply shout “black is beautiful” or de-exotify Asian and Latina bodies. It is to give exactly zero fucks about it. That is an insanely painful process. To learn to love outside the white economy—to learn how to love a black body or a white body or a body raced any other way—is nothing short of miraculous.

Such a love cannot be bought or ruined by the white economy. It would die for its love, because such a love knows that it has nothing to lose in a loss, and nothing to gain in a victory. As I said in my previous piece, “Now—in this shattered, violent, horrible world, with its racist standards of beauty, its heteronormative aims—we affirm our sexual freedom [our freedom to love]. There is no future we can do it in instead.” This is the present; no delusions that we won't die or that we will be vindicated by some future society (we will know even less about them then than we do now, since we'll be dead). We cannot lose ourselves in the fantasy of being good-by-proximity through collective action, cannot tell ourselves that we are responsible for anything but what we do with our own lives. To be perfectly cliché: We must love our neighbor as ourselves.

For many, this a bone lodged in their throat. Freud, famously, understood what a disgusting thought that was, because he recognized that the neighbor, for us, is a monster, a proving-ground for our own superiority, a hostile threat to our own-self worth. Diaz, along with the SJ movement more generally, share this sentiment. (Indeed, the SJ movement is hostile to THINKING—you will often find people crying that “Much theory does not good practice make,” but nearly no one realizes that tripping over themselves like beheaded fowl, just so every other headless cock can see they're doing SOMETHING, is worse. All this talk of Hegel and Nietzsche is so much academic jargon, unlike their own jargon of “privilege” and “white supremacy” and the rest of the inaccessible, clique-centric terms. If not for this anti-intellectual streak, how else do we end up with a decolonial love which is exactly the same as hatred, except that people nurse their hate, name it love, and call it a revolutionary practice?)

Díaz can't seem to imagine me with friends of color, lovers of color, colleagues of color, enemies of color, indifferent strangers of color, and the need to relate to them. Fanon can—“I find myself in the world and I recognize that I have one right alone: That of demanding human behavior from the other”—but Díaz can't. As Audrey Thompson put it in her popular but again, to my eyes, ultimately useless and misguided essay “Tiffany, friend of people of color,” they have no patience for the kind of love I am preaching here: It “is a different question from whether a white person can be the friend of a person of color. Here, I am focusing specifically on the universal 'friend,' as in 'good guy' or 'ally.' Even intimate friendship, though, is not safe from racism. As Lerone Bennett, Jr., suggests, such a relationship may 'transcend' racism without destroying it.” That is an incredibly stupid statement: how can a friendship transcend racism (Hegel, remember, is talking about practical, embodied love for this world)? And even if it could, how can any relationship transcend racism without being a threat to it? And if it can transcend in an unthreatening why, why the fuck are we calling that "transcendence"? All this is is a repetition of the standard SJ dismissal: you are an individualist, but I see things as they really are, on the level of systems and the universal; I think about the “universal 'friend'” (whatever that means!), while you only think about your specific, meaningless individual friends; your petty personal problems are never going to amount to any real change.

Against the sneering superiority of an SJ warrior who has no time for the individual, we should remember the fighting words of the Mishnah—Seder Nezikin, Tractate Sanhedrin, Chapter 4, Mishnah 5: “A single person is created to teach that if any causes a single life to be lost, it is on him as if he has lost a whole world, and if anyone saves a single life, it is on him as if he saved a whole world.”

Dostoevsky knew that all such attempts to love people “generally” are self-defeating: “The more I love mankind in general, the less I love people in particular, that is, individually, as separate persons... On the other hand, it has always happened that the more I hate people individually, the more ardent becomes my love for humanity as a whole.” That is decolonial love in a nutshell.

But the decolonial critic, again, cannot tell the difference between invisible white supremacy and white supremacy destroyed. To do some quick word-substitution on the one of Zen's most famous sayings, on how mountains and rivers are perceived during the steps of enlightenment:

“First, I saw people as people. Then, I saw that people (including myself) were all raced. Then, when I had actually achieved enlightenment, I saw people as people."

The third stage is that of the bodhisattva, the practitioner enabled to cut through delusions and assist others on their quest to their own (unique, singular) enlightenment.
 
So that is the problem: Decolonial love says we must first decolonize our minds, our societies, our groups, our countries; that love, real love, is not possible now, today, that we must strive all our lives—more likely, must work for some future society in which it is possible, even if it will not be possible for us. But Hegelian love tells us that we are already, EXACTLY as we are, in a position to love: in this misery, in this brokenness, in this awfulness, we must love the broken, miserable people we are and who are around us. Decolonial love despises that, because decolonial love is rebranded hatred; Hegelian love is indifferent to the white economy of attraction, and loves without using its reference points.

And let us not be confused that they have the same end goals in mind, but irreconcilable plans to go about it, like the eternal war between the anarchists and the Communists: Hegel promises us no future, while decolonial love depends on one. As Žižek writes elsewhere:

“In short, the ultimate deception lies in the failure to see that one already has what one is looking for... the final reversal of the dialectical process, as we have seen, far from involving the magical intervention of a deus ex machina, is a purely formal turnaround, a shift in perspective: the only thing that changes in the final reconciliation is the subject's standpoint—the subject endorses the loss, re-inscribes it as its triumph. Reconciliation is thus simultaneously both less and more than the standard idea of overcoming an antagonism: less, because nothing 'really changes'; more, because the subject of the process is deprived of its very (particular) substance.” That is, the subject of the racializing process—Diaz's “necolonial” subject—already ceases to exist, because it is revealed as a fiction. Not only is the lie revealed, we now live *as if we really believe in the truth* (as opposed to only paying lip service to it, saying "Yes, I know that is the case, but just the same..."

Again, this is not some detached “transcendence” after which the enlightened can no longer relate to those who do not think like them—indeed, that is a criticism I would level against SJ warriors generally. The point is that such people can no longer be bought. Such a person is enabled, even at the cost of themselves, of their privileges and their friendships and their lives, to wage a war against that which had possessed them and those they love. Such a person is able to love; such a person is no longer an acceptable threat.

Such a person is rare; but such a person loves.

But for Díaz and his type, the third stage of Buddhist enlightenment, or the Hegelian sublation, is exactly the same as stage one, because “nothing changed”; they cannot understand the difference between invisible white supremacy and the end of the white supremacy, the subject who loves outside the white economy in fact instead of deludedly believing there was no white economy they were loving within in the first place; because Díaz and his type “know” that nothing changes between the two positions. They are cynics, and as Lacan warned us about cynics, they're all dupes. “I know how things really are; so I persist in my racial fantasies and fictions of solidarity based on similarity, on calling (as Diaz does) my fellow people of color brothers and sisters because that is what white supremacy believes, not that all are siblings, but we, the oppressed...”

---

So. That's why I can't stand Díaz. He is irrelevant to me; his decolonial love has no way of redeeming the devil. As Propagandhi sings in “Refusing to Be a Man”:

“i won't try to tell you that i'm different from all the rest; i've been subject to the same de-structure of desire and i've felt the same effects; i'm a hetero-sexist tragedy[...] i had different desires prior to my role-remodelling. and at six years of age you don't challenge their claims. you become the same. (or withdraw from the game and hang your head in shame)[...]sex has been distorted and vilified. i'm scared of my attraction to body types. if everything desired is objectified then eroticism needs to be redefined. and i refuse to be a 'man'. dead men don't rape. a gender war in your fucking face. a battle hymn to celebrate the fact that we don't have to become or remain what we've come to hate.”

That's god-damn anti-patriarchal hymn, and has nothing to do with the ressentiment fantasies of the separatists who think only women can be feminists, the Good Social Justice Men who “know” that women need to lead the movement, the intersectional feminists who know we have to account for all identities...

Propagandhi takes responsible for the demonization (lit. “being made into a demon”) that was not his fault and the consequences he will get for throwing it down. There is no idiotic talk about being a “good ally”; Propagandhi is not some altruistic angel fighting “for” women, not someone just trying to mask his attraction to certain body types. Unlike the likes of Macklemore, who will tried to claim that oppressed loves are the “same” as his, Propagandhi knows that white supremacist patriarchy has done unspeakable things to him and his desires, so he is set on setting them all on fire. The same goes for anti-racist work—it is my job to stop believing I am white, not bow and scrape and let POC “lead” the movement as if I, in fact, was not destroyed and demonized by white supremacy.

THAT'S “checking your privilege.” But it's a conception I have never, not once, found articulated by any self-identified member of the “social justice” movement; and it sure as hell has nothing to do with Díaz and his ilk's decolonial fantasies.


So I don't bother with them so much. Down with decolonial love.

Saturday, February 22, 2014

0 What We're Reading Today (2-22-14)

A Dictator's Guide to Urban Design - The Atlantic
Matt Ford

Kiev Truce Shattered, Dozens Killed - The Atlantic

The Dark Power of Fraternities - The Atlantic
Caitlin Flanagan

White-Washing Malcolm X: The Atlantic's View in 1965 - The Atlantic
David A. Graham

The Zombie Numbers That Rule the US Economy - The Atlantic
Zachary Karabell

Among the Believers: What Jalal Al-e Ahmad Thought Iranian Islamism Could Learn From Zionism - Foreign Affairs
Bernard Avishai; Jalal Al-e Ahmad

CFC Talks Love with Author Kiese Laymon - Crunk Feminist Collective
Crunktastic

Musevini's Oil Bet - Foreign Affairs
Vivian Salama

The Cultish Appeal of Michelle Obama - NPR
Linton Weeks

Like It or Not, Most Urban Freeways Are Here to Stay - The Atlantic Cities
Earl Swift

The Commuting Penalty of Being Poor and Black in Chicago - The Atlantic Cities
Emily Badger

Adrian Broadway and Black Teens Under Fire - Ebony
Jamilah Lemieux

A Photographer's Moving Tribute to the Pine Ridge Reservation - Slate
Jordan G. Teicher

As 2 Go Free, Brooklyn Conviction Challenges Keep Pouring In - New York Times
Vivian Yee

On the Killing of Jordan Davis by Michael Dunn - The Atlantic
Ta-Nehisi Coates

The Problem With Little White Girls (and Boys) - Medium
Pippa Biddle

The Incoherent Backlashes to Black Actors Playing 'White' Superheroes - The Atlantic
Noah Berlatsky

I'm the Duke University Freshman Porn Star and for the First Time, I'm Telling the Story in My Words - XO Jane
Lauren A.

We must give the land back: America's brutality toward Native Americans continues today - Salon
Steven Salaita

Richard Sherman and the Problem of Being the Right Kind of Brown Man - Gawker
Gyasi Ross

The Champion Barack Obama - The Atlantic
Ta-Nehisi Coates

Personal Identity Is (Mostly) Performance - The Atlantic
Jennifer Ouellette

MSNBC's Scholar-in-Residence - Slate
Hanna Rosin

40 Years of Photography Destroyed by Hurricane Sandy - Slate
Alyssa Coppelman

40 more maps that explain the world - Washington Post
Max Fisher

via Getty Images

Tuesday, January 28, 2014

0 What We're Reading Today (1-28-14)

Macklemore, White Privilege, and the Grammy For Best Rap Album - Complex
Insanul Ahmed

Why I Will Never Want the "Same Love" - Huffington Post
Jay Dodd

Macklemore is being used to paint the rest of hip-hop as 'uncivil' - Huffington Post
The Guardian

"Same Love," same old shit? - From the Square
Karen Tongson

The Myth of Black Homophobia: Why I'm Not Feeling Macklemore and Why White Saviors Are Anything But - At the Bar
Dennis Upkins

Making Jay Z 'Eat the Cake' - NewBlackMan (in Exile)
Mark Anthony Deal

BOW DOWN, MACKLEMORE: Why 'Same Love' is NOT My Queer Anthem - Guerilla Feminism
Kelly Fox

Obama Is Not a Post-Racial President - Foreign Affairs
Jonathan Holloway

State of the States - New York Times

For New York City's First Lady, a Chief of Staff but Still No Defined Role - New York Times
Michael M. Grynbaum

Ezra Klein vs. Nate Silver: The Wonk Super Bowl - Politico
Dylan Byers

Looking for Insight Among the World's Irks and Quirks - New York Times
Michiko Kakutani

Google Autocomplete Wants to Know Why Post-Communist Europe Is So Poor - The Atlantic
Matthew O'Brien

The 'Product of Its Time' Defense: No Excuse for Sexism and Racism - The Atlantic
Noah Berlatsky

Stanford Man: Richard Sherman and the Thug Athlete Narrative - Grantland
Rembert Browne

Eat the Cake, Anna-Mae - Color Lines
Akiba Solomon

Here's Why You Don't See Romney Reacting to the 47 Percent Video in "Mitt" - Mother Jones
Asawin Suebsaeng

State of the Union: No More Mr. Nice President - Mother Jones
David Corn

College Football Players Are Trying to Unionize, and the NCAA Is Not Happy About It - Mother Jones
Matt Connolly

Charts: Unemployment Benefits' Big Bang for the Buck - Mother Jones
Jaeah Lee, Tasneem Raja, and Brett Brownell


Saturday, January 25, 2014

0 What We're Reading Today (1-25-14)

Your Degrees Will Not Protect You: A Lesson from Richard Sherman - For Harriet
Kimberly Foster

Don Lemon and the Middle Class Embrace of Pathological Blackness - For Harriet
Kimberly Foster

Michael Crabtree as racial remainder - J. Drabinksi
John E. Drabinski

The World's 85 Richest People Are as Wealthy as the Poorest 3 Billion - The Atlantic
Derek Thompson

Can Anyone Stop Hillary? Absolutely - The Atlantic
James A. Barnes

The radical gospel of Martin Luther King - Al Jazeera
Osagyefo Uhuru Sekou

Dopamine and Teenage Logic - The Atlantic
Daniel Siegel

Does the Republican Party Have to Change - The Atlantic
Molly Ball

Richard Sherman: The New, True All-American - The Atlantic
Eric Liu

The Geography of the American Dream - The Atlantic
Derek Thompson

Richard Sherman's Latest and his Refusal to Be a Brand - The Nation
Dave Zirin

Richard Sherman, Racial Coding, and Bombastic Brainiacs - The Nation
Dave Zirin

Study: In Black Men, Internalized Racism Speeds Up Aging - Color Lines
Julianne Hing

Iranian-American Actress Gets Fed Up With Hollywood's Racism - Color Lines
Jamilah King

Richard Sherman: 'Thug' Is the Accepted Way of Saying the N-Word - Color Lines
Jamilah King

This Former Pastor is Going to Spend a Year Doubting God. Great Idea! - Slate
Miriam Krule

The "Would You Like a Ride in My Ferrari?" Gabfest - Slate
Slate's Political Gabfest

The Legacy of Albania's 700,000 Bunkers - Slate
Jordan G. Teicher

Malcolm X & Police Brutality: A Letter to the NYPD - Prison Culture

Poem of the Day: "Cuz He's Black" - Prison Culture

"If I Didn't Sell Drugs, I'd Be Dead": What It's Like to Lose Unemployment Benefits - Mother Jones
Dana Liebelson

The states of our union ... are not all strong - Politico
Margaret Slattery

House aims to finalize farm conference - Politico
David Rogers

What I Am "Looking" For - Huffington Post
Jay Dodd


Sunday, January 19, 2014

0 What We're Reading Today (1-19-14)

James Baldwin and Dick Gregory: "Baldwin's Nigger" (1969) - YouTube
James Baldwin and Dick Gregory

Rickey Vincent on Listen, Whitey!: The Sounds of Black Power 1965-1975 - LA Review of Books
Rickey Vincent

Empire States of Mind: Johnny, Patti, and Jay - LA Review of Books
Jack Hamilton

Free, Black and Blue Ivy - Ebony
Jamilah Lemieux

Hatred of Congress - Five Thirty Eight
Tom Schaller

'You Have to Know History to Actually Teach It' - The Atlantic
David Cutler

Spoken and Unspoken - NPR
Various

What Bill de Blasio Can Learn From New York City's Last Radical Mayor - The Nation
D.D. Guttenplan

Will Black Deaths Matter in de Blasio's New York? - The Nation
Mychal Denzel Smith

Why We're More Creative When We're Tired and 9 Other Surprising Things About How Brains Work - Fast Company
Belle Beth Cooper

The Most-Read Leadership Stories of 2013 - Fast Company
Kathleen Davis

How Kids Dealt With the Stress of Desegregation - The Atlantic
Jennie Rothenberg Gritz

The Danger of Telling Poor Kids That College Is the Key to Social Mobility - The Atlantic
Andrew Simmons

It Is Expensive to Be Poor - The Atlantic
Barbara Ehrenreich

Neal Brennan -- White America's Greatest Klingon Writer - The Atlantic
Ta-Nehisi Coates

Hitler on the Mississippi Banks - The Atlantic
Ta-Nehisi Coates

What It Means to Be a Public Intellectual - The Atlantic
Ta-Nehisi Coates

The Smartest Nerd in the Room - The Atlantic
Ta-Nehisi Coates

The Great Brain: Why the NFL needs Peyton Manning even more than the Broncos do - Slate
Jack Hamilton

James Baldwin's Paris - New York Times
Ellery Washington

The Problems with the Common Core - Rethinking Schools
Stan Karp

The Amiri Baraka I Knew - Cold Drank
Darnell Moore

Mr. Castro Goes to Washington - Texas Monthly
Joaquin Castro

Obama's Changes to Government Surveillance - New York Times
Josh Keller, Alicia Parlapiano, David E. Sanger, and Charlie Savage


Sunday, January 5, 2014

0 The Apologetic Body | Bodies of Critique, Respectability, and Resistance

            In the words of acclaimed writer Dream Hampton, the anatomy of an apology is as follows: 1)I’m sorry, 2) Here’s my understanding of how I hurt you. 3) I will never do that again. Various PR blogs expand upon this idea by stating  it is important to note tone/intent, delivery, and actions to follow. Apologies are a mainstay in our culture and we often hold popular and powerful figures to the same acts of penance that we expect from our close friends and family. I understand this phenomenon. Celebrities and pundits and politicians alike are responsible as cultural influences. They carry with them platforms to create, defend and critique seemingly personal opinions and beliefs. When you feel they have offended, I understand the desire to make them apologize. To apologize requires a person to take the blame and shame of committing a wrong or an offense; offering in the end some sort of retribution. But I think we have used apologies to further victimize particular bodies.
            Last week MSNBC political pundit and Tulane University Professor, Melissa Harris Perry hosted an end of the year rap up where a host of comedians were to provide captions to some of the years most iconic photographs. Upon a Romney familyportrait featuring Kieran Romney, the adopted Black grandson to the Former Republican Presidential Candidate, the panel burst into laughter. Actor and performer Pia Glenn alluded to the Sesame Street maxim, “one of these things is not like the other…” and Dean Obeidallah noted it was a analogy for finding a Black person in a Republican National convention. Perry supported and validated these statements citing her personal history with the Mormon faith. Despite her valid interest into the critique the media spiraled into frenzy shaming her and her panel. She immediately apologized via Twitter, then public statement on her show.

In a particularly cutting attack,CNN’s personal Uncle Don Lemon attempts to shame Perry for crossing a line. After pitting his two-person panel against each other, he dives into a commentary about the nature of MSNBC’s critiques of him. In his opening point he mentions he doesn’t respond to them and quotes “the dog is suppose to howl at the moon, the moon isn’t suppose to howl back.” How are we to understand that? How are we to understand his positioning as somehow unavailable to critique? Yet he stands here demanding that of one of his colleagues? Don, for whatever reason, features Marc Lamont Hill who vehemently calls Lemon on his attempted color-blind respectability bullshit. Talk of double standards and context ensue and critiques of comedy and intent remain.
The central aspect of the critique is that we cannot make fun of people’s families, especially their children. This concept of saving our children, or protecting our children (though there seems to be a preference for white or transnational) is a complex and divisive one in America. I, in no way, believe mocking or shaming adoption however it may occur is fair. However, there is a deeper problem here.  As I’ve written before as defense, Perry and her panel were not mocking  the child but calling to light the exploitative nature of transracial adoption. While there must be a myriad of narratives from transracial(and transnational) adoptive families, I have seen and heard particular traumas that these children have faced. The erasure of history and difference, the denial of cultural awareness. But the central issue here is the way Melissa Harris Perry was personally attacked and vilified. The way her “colleagues,” specifically a fellow correspondent of color could dare erase her lived experience and fair critique under some guise of respectable humor or commentary.
While I have the utmost respect for Perry’s apology, its slays me the outcry her comments produced. It slays me that fellow news correspondents demand her resignation. She and her panel simply highlighted whiteness at its core. They highlighted how the diversity discourses place bodies of color at the crux of their narrative. What slays me is how Don Lemon works in this way for whiteness. He works in terms of respectability and aspiration. He works in the notion of colorblind equality. He’s only resistance is that to act of resistance. It is viscerally uncomfortable for him to face the truth of racial difference. But why? How does his token, respectability jargon do? He is a living apology. He apologizes for “under performing Blacks,” for “saggy pants wearing Blacks,” for the echoes of Moynihan Blacks. His apology, though, completely undermines the ways Black bodies and other bodies of color act out their resistance. Melissa Harris Perry resists in the ways she sees fit in the face of her class and education privilege. She calls out her location and still holds herself and panel to the fire on countless episodes. She can critique and praise news media and her work is informative and accessible. (I am not going to question or critique her radicalness because there to understand resistance we must see all forms of it). And here we find her apologizing. It is sincere and heartfelt but in my mind horribly unfair. I would share the video below but I don’t want to reproduce a Black Woman’s shame especially for something so scathingly unfair.

Despite his problems, Lemon’s remarks that we can all learn something about apologies from Perry are unfortunately too accurate. She did not excuse her actions but clearly stated how she understood her defense and reestablished the barrier she intends to not cross. We find in her speech the anatomy of an apology. We find the heart of how to make right a wrong. However, we have too many women of color having to apologize, for being assaulted, for being killed, for protecting their bodies, for protecting their families. We have too many men and men of color demanding such apologies from women. It is ironic then that we on the body of Dream Hampton we find an anatomy of an apology, we find it ironic that the most heartfelt apology of the year so far is that of a Black woman.  We assume certain repentance from these bodies and ridicule them until the apologize for being, for speaking, for demanding, for resisting. . While we should know how to repent for trespasses ; we must be wary who is truly trespassing against us. If there was any doubt #IStandWithMHP and Pia Glenn.


for any feedback, comments or critiques find me on twitter @jayydodd 

Tuesday, December 31, 2013

0 2K14: A Critical Fuck U2 Homelessness

 By Tabias Wilson

  "A chair is still a chair
Even when there's no one sittin' there
But a chair is not a house
And a house is not a home
When there's no one there to hold you tight
And no one there you can kiss goodnight"

-Luther Vandross/Dionne Warwick
 A House is Not A Home


It's necessary to begin this manifesto with the recognition that I have spent little time sleeping on the physical streets of America. I'm not well-versed in the act of survival without a physical covering, nor would I feel comfortable identifying as homeless in the public policy notion of the word. This is no means an attempt to belittle the struggle(s) of the physically homeless in America or worldwide, neither is it an attempt to use their experience as a transaction necessary for expression. However I tend to identity with the old Luther Vandross/Dionne Warwick tune "A House Is Not A Home."

"Lying, thinking
Last night
How to find my soul a home
Where water is not thirsty
And bread loaf is not stone
I came up with one thing
And I don't believe I'm wrong
That nobody,
But nobody
Can make it out here alone."
-Maya Angelou


When thinking through the notion of home, and it's role in my living, I have found two definitions to be of good use. The first (noun) "the place where one lives permanently, esp. as a member of a family or household" and the second (adjective) "of or relating to the place where one lives." Home seems to be commonly conceptualized as a place where living takes place. The first definition speaks of a permanent space where one lives as a member of group that is bound by love, blood or common connection to the space. The second definition, that of the adjective, is squarely centered on the space where one lives. Taken together both definitions present home as a place central to living and being alive and full of life, if not thriving.


“If I didn't define myself for myself, I would be crunched into other people's fantasies for me and eaten alive.” 
-Audre Lorde
 

Growing up black, queer and radical here, I've almost always had a roof over my head; my grandmothers, mother, aunts and cousins (all women) have always made sure of that. This roof was sustained by the strength, scars and endurance of their backs. However, I cannot say that I've ever had a home. This did not quite occur to me until a recent conversation with a close friend about going "home" for the holidays. I've never been one to long for "home" over the breaks of college. Not because I didn't love my family or my relatives, but because I wasn't quite sure what home meant. From his tone, and that of others, home seemed to be a place where one found strength, companionship and unity with those who you were most bonded with in kinship or common purpose or his-story. I hadn't quite experienced that and in that moment of our conversation, I realized that this "home" is what I'd always been looking for. Of course, I'd always found love from my family, friends and relatives but that love was targeted, marketed and intended for certain sections of being while syphoning life from other layers of my self. My family and poc community showered their love on the things about me they made me most like them: my blackness,laugh, lips, wit, blunt nature and determination while unintentionally marking my queerness and critical consciousness as unwarranted excess. My (LGBT/straight/non-queer) friends and acquaintances loved and strengthened my commitment to critical inquiry, the process of loving, activism and honesty but generally through a heterosexist lens. My (non-poc) queer community nurtured my queer ethic and ability to thrive in same-sex relationships, but often at the expense of my blackness. Blaqueer communities healed the rupture between my queerness and blackness creating a particular fierceness still untheorized, but often at the expense of my masculine performances and anti-sexist ethics. I was a man with many houses to visit but no home to dwell in.

"i believe in living
i believe in birth.
i believe in the sweat of love
and in the fire of truth"
-Assata Shakur


I say all this to bring light to the state of solidarity and love in queer communities and communities of color. At a time where intersectionality has become the buzzword of choice, what does it say that our intersections have become traffic jams locked in a parilysis of identity centric affections? While such targeted demonstrations of love, healing and support are necessary important--if not done with the totality of the person in mind--we risk creating and sustaining a new type of isolation based upon the number of intersections or (identity) layers that a sister/brother may have. In our zeal to heal the wounds made raw by systems of violence, we risk circumcising and dividing the very self we wish to empower and make whole. By ignoring, displacing or antagonising the divergent and diverse features of those minoritized within our communities we risk discarding the foundation of a home for the creation of a temporary shelter. If love is to be noted and performed as a commitment to the creation of mutual growth--spiritual, emotional, economic and intellectual-we must be sure that this growth is experienced in all journeys of living.

In 2K14 I'm committing myself to the creation of loving, healing spaces that exclude only subordinating powers and privileges. For these spaces-and a movement of radical love and restorative justice-I must first commit myself to the loving of individuals and communities that I've long feared and never met. I must confront the other within and the fear of being furthered othered by association and disassociation with particular narratives of being and unbecoming. For my blaqueerness to exist unencumbered I must first commit myself to resistance to colonial systems of power based on violent circumcision of self and other. To do that, I must first love me while also endeavoring to love you and that which you are not. That perhaps is the strongest fuck you to homelessness I can attempt.






 

Snakes On McCain Copyright © 2011 - |- Template created by O Pregador - |- Powered by Blogger Templates